urbanary

Top Italian Restaurants in Carlisle: Pizza, Pasta & More

The best Italian restaurants in Carlisle are La Mezzaluna, Amatos and Gianni's Pizzeria, ranked on fit, venue quality, freshness and area spread from the 9 places that fit (November 2026).

The best Italian restaurants in Carlisle, from pizza to fresh pasta and everything in between. Every place here serves Italian food or pizza.

The ranked list

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9

Quick answers

How many Italian restaurants does Urbanary list in Carlisle?
9 places in Carlisle fit this guide (November 2026). We recount from our venue data at least once a day.
How is this Carlisle list ranked?
By our published scoring rules: tag match, venue quality, freshness and area spread. No venue can pay to move up the core rankings.
What's the top pick right now?
La Mezzaluna tops the list, with Amatos and Gianni's Pizzeria close behind.

More Carlisle plans