Magic Potions Tavern

You'll find yourself descending into something properly atmospheric on Blair Street—this isn't your standard pub crawl destination. Magic Potions Tavern leans hard into theatricality without tipping into gimmick territory, with dim lighting and a carefully curated drinks menu that actually justifies the fuss. The cocktails are technically sound rather than just Instagram-bait, and the staff know what they're doing. It's the kind of place where you can tell they've thought about the experience, from the decor down to what's in your glass.