Toll House Inn

You'll spot the Toll House's distinctive Georgian frontage as you head down Penny Street towards the castle – this is Lancaster drinking at its most atmospheric. Step inside and you're immediately struck by the low beams, flagstone floors, and that particular smell of old wood and well-kept ale that only comes with centuries of proper pub service. The bar spans several interconnected rooms, each with its own character, from the cosy snug perfect for an intimate pint to the larger dining areas where locals settle in for Sunday roasts. The beer selection runs from reliable Yorkshire bitters to rotating craft options, while the food menu does hearty pub grub without trying to be something it's not. Open from breakfast through to evening, it's become one of those rare places that works whether you're after morning coffee, a working lunch, or settling in for the night with friends.