Tatlers

You're walking up Tombland—that proper medieval street with the cathedral looming—and you slip into Tatlers. It's the kind of place that doesn't need to shout about itself. The dining room has a grown-up, unhurried feel; this isn't somewhere you're rushing through. The kitchen takes real care with what comes out, and the fact that locals keep coming back with a 4.8 rating suggests they're doing something genuinely right. It's the restaurant equivalent of knowing what you're doing without making a fuss about it.