Creameo

Head down to Ecclesall Road and you'll find Creameo doing something proper with desserts—proper homemade ice cream, creative sundaes, and the kind of sweet stuff that actually tastes like someone's bothered. It's the sort of spot where you pop in for a quick cone and end up staying longer because everything looks too good to rush through. The vibe is refreshingly unpretentious; locals clearly rate it, and the consistently high reviews suggest they're not messing about with their recipes or ingredients.