Onzo Pizzeria

You're walking down the harbourside, past the working boats and gift shops, when you spot this place tucked into an actual old lifeboat station. It's that kind of St Ives detail that makes the town work—proper heritage buildings getting a second life. Inside, it's warm and unpretentious, the kind of spot where locals actually eat rather than just tourists passing through. The pizza is done right: wood-fired, properly charred bases, toppings that don't overwhelm the dough. Sit by the window and you've got the harbour spreading out in front of you, which doesn't hurt.