The Five Arches Tavern

You'll find yourself in the heart of Tenby's old town, where The Five Arches sits like it's been part of the furniture forever. It's the kind of place where regulars have their spots, the bartender knows what you're drinking before you order, and the buzz feels earned rather than manufactured. The real ales rotate regularly, the cask selection's taken seriously, and you'll spot locals propping up the bar alongside visitors who've stumbled in by accident and decided to stay. It's unpretentious drinking done well—proper pints, genuine conversation, no pretence.